Raster or Vector Maps: Which One to Choose?

Raster and vector maps represent the territory in different ways. Discover the main differences, advantages and limitations of each type and which one to choose according to your needs.

Introduction

When working with digital maps, two fundamental ways of representing geographic data can be encountered: raster maps and vector maps. Although both can represent the same territory, the way they store and display information is very different.

The choice between raster and vector therefore depends not only on the quality of the map, but mainly on how it will be used. A scanned topographic map, an online road map and a collection of OpenStreetMap trails can represent the same geographic area using completely different technologies.

Who This Article Is For

Anyone who uses digital maps for hiking and cycling
Anyone who needs to choose between raster and vector cartography
Anyone who uses maps, GPS tracks and geographic data with OkMap

Topics Covered

How raster maps are represented
How vector maps are represented
Advantages and limitations of the two approaches
Which type of map to choose in different situations
Using raster and vector maps with OkMap

Raster Maps: Georeferenced Images

A raster map consists of an image made up of a grid of pixels. Each pixel contains information about the color or value of the image and, when the map is georeferenced, the position of the pixels can be associated with real geographic coordinates.

Raster maps are particularly suitable for representing already processed cartography, such as topographic maps, hiking maps, orthophotos and historical maps. The graphic appearance of the map is preserved, allowing the user to display exactly the symbols, colors, contour lines, texts and other elements present in the original cartography.

Raster maps can also be divided into tiles, as frequently happens with Web maps and many cartographic formats intended for navigation.

Vector Maps: Geographic Objects

A vector map represents the territory using geometric elements such as points, lines and polygons. These elements can describe roads, trails, buildings, waterways, contour lines, boundaries and points of interest.

Vector elements can be managed individually: they can be selected, modified, queried and displayed with different graphic properties. Organizing data into vector themes also makes it possible to separate different categories of geographic information.

Vector maps are therefore particularly suitable when the goal is to work with geographic objects rather than only with their graphic representation.

Raster and Vector Compared

The main difference concerns the way information is represented. In raster maps, information is associated with image pixels; in vector maps it is associated with geometries and their attributes.

Characteristic	Raster Map	Vector Map
Representation	Pixels	Points, lines and polygons
Cartographic appearance	Preserves the original image	Generated from the representation of objects
Editing individual elements	Limited	Possible directly on the objects
Querying objects	Limited	Particularly suitable
Zoom	Limited by image resolution	Objects can be redrawn at different scales
Scanned cartography	Very suitable	Not directly applicable
Managing geographic objects	Less suitable	Very suitable

When to Choose a Raster Map

A raster map is generally the most natural choice when you want to use an existing map while preserving its original appearance. It is particularly useful when the cartography contains graphic information that is difficult to represent as individual vector objects.

For example, a paper topographic map acquired by scanning can be georeferenced and used as a raster map. This makes it possible to overlay GPX tracks, waypoints and other geographic data without having to digitally reconstruct all the elements of the map.

Raster is also particularly suitable when you want to faithfully preserve a specific cartographic symbology, such as that used in traditional hiking or topographic maps.

When to Choose a Vector Map

A vector map is particularly useful when it is important to work with individual geographic objects. Roads, trails, buildings, points of interest and other elements can be selected, modified, filtered or displayed using different styles.

This approach is particularly useful when the map needs to be updated, queried or combined with other information. It is also possible to change the graphic representation of elements according to the zoom level or the user's needs.

Vector maps are therefore often an effective choice for data derived from OpenStreetMap or other geographic databases in which objects need to be managed separately.

Raster and Vector Can Be Used Together

The two types of data are not necessarily alternatives. In many situations, a raster map can be used as a cartographic base and vector data, such as trails, roads, waypoints, points of interest or other geographic elements, can be overlaid on it.

This approach makes it possible to combine the advantages of both representations: the raster map preserves the detail and symbology of the original cartography, while vector data can be selected, modified and managed independently of the base map.

For Hiking and Cycling: Which One to Choose?

For hiking and cycling, both solutions can be valid. The choice mainly depends on the type of information you want to have on the map.

A raster topographic map may be preferable when the level of detail, symbology and appearance of the original map are important. It is often a good solution for viewing traditional hiking cartography together with your own GPS tracks.

A vector map may instead be preferable when you want to dynamically display roads, trails and points of interest, or when you want to modify or query individual geographic elements.

It is not always necessary to choose only one solution. In many situations, raster and vector data can be used simultaneously by overlaying different information layers over the same area.

Raster and Vector Maps in OkMap

OkMap allows you to use both types of cartography and combine them with tracks, waypoints and other geographic data. Raster maps can be imported, georeferenced and used in the numerous raster formats supported by the software.

For vector data, OkMap allows you to manage geometric elements organized into themes, with options for display, editing and querying. The software also supports importing data from sources such as OpenStreetMap.

The ability to overlay maps and different types of data makes it possible, for example, to use a raster map as a topographic base while simultaneously displaying trails, waypoints or other vector data on top of it.

There Is No Universally Better Choice

Raster and vector are not competing technologies in an absolute sense. They meet different needs and can often be used together on the same map.

If you want to preserve the appearance of an existing map, a raster map is generally the most suitable solution. If, on the other hand, you want to work with individual geographic objects, modify them, query them or represent them dynamically, a vector map offers more possibilities. In many cases, combining the two types provides the most complete result.

Practical Tips

Use a raster map when you want to faithfully preserve the appearance of an existing map.
Prefer a vector map when you need to work with individual geographic objects.
Always check the quality and resolution of the raster map before using it.
When possible, combine raster and vector data to take advantage of both representations.

Common Errors

Assuming that a vector map is automatically more detailed than a raster map.
Confusing the ability to zoom in on a vector map with the presence of more geographic information.
Using a raster scan without proper georeferencing.
Considering raster and vector maps as necessarily exclusive alternatives.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a raster map and a vector map?

A raster map consists of an image made up of pixels, while a vector map represents geographic objects using geometries such as points, lines and polygons.

Is a raster map or a vector map better?

There is no universally better choice. Raster maps are particularly suitable for displaying already processed cartography, while vector maps are more suitable when individual geographic elements need to be managed, queried or modified.

Are vector maps always more detailed than raster maps?

No. The level of detail depends on the data used. A high-resolution raster map can contain much more visual detail than a vector map with only a few elements.

Which type of map is best for hiking?

It depends on the intended use. A raster topographic map may be preferable when preserving the appearance and content of the original cartography is important, while a vector map is particularly useful for dynamically displaying and managing roads, trails, points of interest and other geographic elements.

Summary

Raster maps represent the territory using pixels and are particularly suitable for displaying already processed cartography. Vector maps instead represent the territory using geometric objects, offering greater possibilities for managing and editing individual elements. The choice therefore depends on the intended use and, in many cases, the best solution is to use both types simultaneously.

Want to Apply These Concepts with OkMap?

After reading the technical articles, you can learn more with practical video tutorials or download OkMap Desktop and work directly with maps, GPX tracks and GPS data.

Download Manual Video tutorials

Free software for Windows - Complete PDF manual - Video tutorials